top of page

GUEST COLUMN.

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management

TRANSFORMING STATE HR SYSTEMS

By Kelly Hardwick, Mississippi State Personnel Director and President of the National Association of State Personnel Executives

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management

Across state governments, similar pressures are pushing leaders to take a hard look at classification and compensation systems they have leaned on for years. Competition for talent, a growing interest in skills-based hiring and promotion, employees who expect room to grow, and work that keeps changing faster than the paperwork have all exposed the limits of frameworks that in some cases have gone decades without a meaningful update.


This work is not just about refreshing job titles and pay ranges. It is about building a system that lets people move, lets agencies adapt, and gives employees a reason to stay. Real reform pulls in agencies, managers, employees, budget officials, policymakers, and the folks at the top.


An outdated classification system quietly makes everything harder. It boxes people in, muddies pay decisions, and leaves employees guessing about how to get ahead.

Managers cannot recruit for skills that did not exist when the system was written; they cannot move good people where they are needed; and employees cannot see the next rung on the ladder.


Over the years, states have piled up hundreds and sometimes thousands of narrow classifications, each written for one situation and then never retired. Modernization usually means collapsing that thicket into broader occupational families and career bands. You end up with more consistency and, at the same time, more room for agencies to adjust as their needs change.


Designing for the Future


Much of the conversation among HR officials at the late July conference of the National Association of State Personnel Executives (NASPE), turned to building systems that can bend with whatever comes next, especially as artificial intelligence starts to change the work itself.


Talk about AI has moved past the hypothetical. State leaders are now asking practical questions about how these tools change what a job actually involves, what skills it calls for, and who is being groomed to step up next. As agencies bring the tools in, the job descriptions and classifications underneath them have to keep pace.


Instead of pinning everything to narrowly defined jobs, many states are shifting toward broader occupational categories and skill-based career paths. That gives employees room to grow and move, and it gives agencies room to respond when the demands change.


AI may also turn out to be a tool for the work itself, not just a reason for it. There was real interest in using it to spot positions that are all but identical, flag classifications that duplicate one another, and keep the whole system consistent. For a state trying to simplify and then maintain a sprawling classification structure, that could be a genuine help.


From Recommendations to Reality


Efforts to reform HR policy changes calls for money, new technology, and leadership that stays committed after the excitement wears off. A study can tell you what needs fixing and that takes planning and steady coordination among many people who do not always report to the same person. In addition, the improvements only last if you are willing to overhaul the underlying system rather than patch it.


Funding is its own hurdle, especially once pay is on the table. The states that get somewhere tend to pick their priorities, put the changes in order, and move in phases they can actually manage, rather than trying to do everything in a single stroke.


Building Trust


Employees and managers want to know one thing above all: how does this affect me, my pay, my job, and where I am headed? The states that succeed at reform, treat communication as something you keep doing, not a one-time announcement you make and move on from.


HR, managers, executives, finance, and employees all need to be in the loop from the start. When people understand the goals, how decisions are being made, and what to expect, there is less rumor and more buy-in.


Managers in particular need practical guidance and training, or they will each apply the new structure their own way in hiring, workforce planning, and developing their people.

 

Recommendations


While there are no silver bullets that guarantee success with HR reform, there are some general principles that will make a big difference. Here are half a dozen:

 

·        Start with the data. Turnover, recruitment trouble, where your pay stands, and what employees are telling you are the ground on which you build every decision.


·        Get your leadership aligned early. Executive sponsors, agency heads, budget officials, and HR need to be reading from the same page on goals and priorities. And do not forget the legislature. Your allies there can carry the project when you cannot.


·        Bring people along the whole way. Employees and agencies support what they

helped shape and understand, and they resist what gets handed to them cold.


·        Call your counterparts in other states. Most are glad to share what worked, what did not, and the materials they built, and it will keep you from stepping in the same holes they did.


·        Expect the unexpected. I can speak to this one from experience. Like the rest of the states, our work here in Mississippi ran straight into he pandemic that upended how everyone operated, and partway through we lost our key consultant to cancer. On top of that, we found hundreds of employees who could not tell us for certain who their supervisor was or which agency employed them, and plenty who had no email or computer to complete a role survey in the first place. You cannot plan for all of that, but you can build a team and a timeline with enough give to survive it.


·        Finally, do not treat this as a project with an end date. Classification, compensation, and job architecture need tending. Workforce needs shift, the labor market moves, and the technology keeps changing, and the system has to be governed and maintained right along with them.

 

At the end of the day, modernizing classification, compensation, and job architecture is not an HR exercise. It is an investment in whether the state can do its work. The states that build simpler, more flexible, and forward-looking structures will have an easier time hiring good people, helping them grow, and delivering for the citizens they serve.


The contents of this Guest Column are those of the author, and not necessarily Barrett and Greene, Inc


#StateandLocalGovernmentHumanResources #StateandLocalGovernmentHR #StateJobClassificationModernization #StateandLocalHumanResourcesReform #StateClassificationAndCompensationReform #StateOutdatedJobClassification #StateClassificationAndCompensationSystems #StateHumanResourcModernization #StateGovernmentJobArchitecture #StateandLocalHumanResourceFlexibility #MississippiStateHumanResources #NationalAssociationStatePersonnelExecutives #NASPE #StateHumanResourceSystemTransformation #StateandLoclEmployeeRelations #StateandLocalGovernmentHiring #StateandLocalRetention #StateandLocalWorkforceManagement #StateandLocalSkillsBasedHiring #StateandLocalJobTitlesAndPayRanges #StateandLocalClassificationReformRecommendations #KellyHardwick #BandGGuestColumn #BarrettandGreeneInc  

GUEST COLUMN ARCHIVES

GUEST COLUMN ARCHIVES.
 

READING THE SEISMOGRAPH OF GOVERNMENT DRIFT

DATA CENTERS: FINDING THE PERSUADABLE MIDDLE

YOUR TRAINING OFFICER IS NOT OVERHEAD

WHY TODAY’S EFFICIENCY PUSH COULD STALL IN THE STATES

HR: SOLUTIONS FOR A SYSTEM UNDER PRESSURE

GRANTMAKING: A POWERFUL GOVERNMENT TOOL

WHY US GOVERNMENTS SHOULD BENCHMARK THE WORLD

REWRITING THE PLAYBOOK ON PUBLIC WORKS RECRUITMENT

WHY COLLABORATION IS OUR COMPETETIVE ADVANTAGE

FOCUSING ON THE POSITIVE

Bridging the Academic/Practitioner Gap: Public Finance Journal

HUMAN SERVICES AS PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE

TRANSLATING PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT INTO ACTION

CIVIC ENGAGEMENT IN HIGHER EDUCATION

REFORMING PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION

WHEN THE DATA CHALLENGES YOU TO CHANGE

A COMPELLING SCORECARD FOR DEMOCRACY

SOCIAL MEDIA: BUILDING TRUST IN GOVERNMENT

MICHIGAN ROADMAP FOR REGULATORY EFFECTIVENESS

THE PAYOFFS TO PUBLIC SECTOR WORKFORCE INVESTMENT

FROM DATA AMBITION TO PUBLIC VALUE

INSPIRATIONAL WOMEN: THE FOOTPRINTS WE LEAVE

PERFORMANCE IN A TIME OF INSTABILITY

UNDERSTANDING MUNICIPAL FISCAL HEALTH

HOW AGENCY HEADS CAN FIX TRAINING

THINKING LIKE A COALITION DESIGNER

AI WEARINESS

THE MASSIVE PHYSICAL IMPACT OF DATA CENTERS

SPECIAL EDUCATION FUNDING: WHERE THE REAL RISK LIES

COUNTIES AND THE BIG SHIFT

CIVIL SERVICE MERIT VS EMPLOYMENT AT WILL

PLANNERS ARE PILLARS OF DEMOCRACY

HOW TO GET BETTER OUTCOMES IN EDUCATION

SMART SHORTCUTS FOR SMARTER BUDGETS

MEASURING SAFETY AND GETTING IT RIGHT

TIME TO MEET THE TRILLION-DOLLAR CHALLENGE

DEVALUING BLACK AND HISPANIC LATINA HOUSING IN CITIES

USING AUTOMATION TO INCREASE AUDIT PRODUCTIVITY

PUBLIC INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM FOR GOOD

A TALENT POOL FOR THE PUBLIC SECTOR

“EFFICIENCY IS NOT AN EXCUSE FOR PARALYSIS”

ART AND SCIENCE OF CREATING CONTRACTS

REFLECTIONS OF A RECENTLY DEPARTED HR DIRECTOR

“HAPPY EMPLOYEES: HAPPY RESIDENTS”

HOW TO TURN A STATE WORKFORCE INTO A TEAM

BUILDING RESILIENT TEAMS TO NAVIGATE UNCERTAINTY

BUILDING CAPACITY FOR CROSS-SECTOR COLLABORATION

GOVERNMENTAL MISTAKES THAT LIVE FOREVER

RESTORING PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN GOVERNMENT

WHAT DOES OVERSIGHT LEADERSHIP LOOK LIKE?

AFFORDABLE HOUSING: BUILDING A BRIGHTER FUTURE

RETHINKING THE MOTIVATION FOR AI

LET'S BE POSITIVE ABOUT GOVERNMENT AGAIN

THE DATA ILLUSION IN PUBLIC SAFETY

ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS AND THE HOUSING CRISIS

A ROUTE TO EXTREME WEATHER RESILIENCE

DECLINING TRUST UNDERMINES DEMOCRACY

FIVE WAYS TO GET READY FOR GENERATION ALPHA

AN OPEN BANKING PATH TO PUBLIC BENEFITS

IT DEPENDS ON WHAT YOU MEAN BY "EFFICIENCY"

HOW AI IS SHAPING DIGITAL ACCESSIBILITY

COST SAVINGS VS EFFICIENCY

NAVIGATING CHAOS

INVESTING IN COMMUNITY

HOW TO GET A LEGISLATOR TO LISTEN

HOW THE IOWA PIE PROGRAM IS SAVING TAXPAYER DOLLARS

HOW SHIFTING DEMOGRAPHICS ARE RESHAPING STATE FINANCES

A REMINISCENCE FROM R. KINNEY POYNTER

REPEAL OF THE MUNI-BOND TAX EXEMPTION WOULD THREATEN US INFRASTRUCTURE

ATTRACTING PUBLIC SERVICE LEADERS WHEN THE AXE HITS THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT

INSPIRATIONAL WOMEN IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT: HOPE IN POLARIZATION

FEDERAL JOB LOSSES EQUAL LOCAL OPPORTUNITIES

THREE ROUTES TO BETTER PROJECT MANAGEMENT

THE POWER OF UNITY

CUTBACK MANAGEMENT: STRATEGY, EVALUATION AND BLAME

BUILDING BROADBAND: THE VISION AND REAL WORLD

STATE BUDGETS: MANAGING EXPECTATIONS AS CONDITIONS RETURN TO NORMAL

HOW CAN LOCAL GOVERNMENTS IMPROVE HEALTH FOR OLDER AMERICANS?

THE AUDACITY OF NOPE

SUBVERSION AS A PUBLIC VALUE

HOW CAN WE PROVIDE ENOUGH EV CHARGERS?

PREPARING TODAY FOR RISING TIDES TOMORROW

A NOVEL REASON WHY GOVERNMENT CONSOLIDATIONS MIGHT MAKE SENSE

SUSTAINING DATA PRACTICES IN MAYORAL TRANSITIONS

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY IN TRANSITION

LESSONS FROM THE WESTERNS

IS YOUR GOVERNMENT PERFORMING BETTER THAN A YEAR AGO?

THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF PUBLIC LIBRARIES IN URBAN REVITALIZATION

STATE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY PERFORMANCE

THE HIGHER ED ROLE IN FILLING THE EMPLOYEE VOID

KEYS TO CONNECTING STATE GOVERNMENT AND PHILANTHROPY

NAVIGATING THE TECH LANDSCAPE: A GUIDE FOR GOVERNMENT

VIRGINIA’S DRIVE-TO-WORK PROGRAM IS A LIFELINE TO ECONOMIC SECURITY

DOES GETTING TOUGHER ON CRIME MAKE PEOPLE SAFER?

EQUITY: THE STATE OF THE STATES

WHAT MOTIVATES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO USE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT?

FEDERALISM IN 2025 AND BEYOND

IS THE FOUR-DAY WORKWEEK IN YOUR FUTURE?

HOW CAN AI MODERNIZE TAX ADMINISTRATION?

HOW STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN SUPPORT CLEAN ENERGY

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management, inspirational women, sponsors, Privacy

 

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Managemen

SIGN UP FOR SPECIAL NEWS JUST FOR YOU.

Get exclusive subscriber-only links to news and articles and the latest information on this website sent directly in your inbox.

Thanks for Subscribing. You'll now recieve updates directly to your inbox.

Copyright @ Barrett and Greene, Inc.  |  All rights Reserved  |  Built By Boost  |  Privacy 212-684-5687  |  greenebarrett@gmail.com

bottom of page