top of page

GUEST COLUMN.

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management

THE DATA ILLUSION IN PUBLIC SAFETY

By Jacob Cramer, Director of Data Innovation, ForceMetrics; former Analysis Administrator, Tucson Police Department

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management

Many people assume police departments have their data systems figured out. They think when a crime happens, departments can instantly pull up every relevant detail, prior 911 calls and incidents, arrest history and even a suspect’s mental health background. But that vision is far from true.

 

The systems upon which law enforcement depends are often disconnected. Critical information sits in silos, locked away in outdated software or inaccessible databases. We’ve built a world where agencies have more data to reference than ever before but using that data to improve public safety is still incredibly hard. To fix this, we need a coordinated push for interoperability through shared standards, open architecture and regional data-sharing frameworks that empower -- not hinder -- first responders. The technology exists today. What’s needed now is the leadership to connect it.

 

Data Silos Inside the Same Department

 

Even within a single department, data are often fragmented. You’ll often find separate systems for 911 calls, criminal reports, traffic citations, bodycam footage, training records, policies, and more. None of them were built to talk to each other. That means officers responding to a call might not see a subject’s prior incidents or relevant behavioral health history, even if the data exist somewhere else in their own department’s systems.

 

It’s not uncommon to see command staff export spreadsheets manually just to stitch together a basic view of a case or community trend. That’s a risky workaround in a field where every second matters.

 

One of the biggest hurdles is that many of the tools used in public safety are proprietary, with many vendors amassing data and building systems that only work with their own software. These so-called “walled gardens” are problematic and often mean that agencies get locked into long-term contracts and closed platforms, making it almost impossible to integrate with other tools or share information seamlessly between jurisdictions.

 

The result is duplication, inefficiency and blind spots that compromise both officer effectiveness and public trust. Instead of streamlining access to the right data, these systems keep it trapped in silos.

 

Disconnected Crimes and Missing Patterns

 

The challenge isn’t only technical. Local politics, different IT capabilities across departments, and entrenched habits all play a role. Departments can be territorial about their data, and I’ve even worked with agencies where divisions within the same building wouldn’t share information. The situation gets even more complicated when you add courts, jails and social services into the mix. Everyone agrees that more connected systems would help. But making it happen requires collaboration, infrastructure and most of all, trust.

 

For example, in the Bay Area, organized retail theft groups often hit multiple stores in different cities in a single day. Without effective methods of sharing data across jurisdictions, each department may see only one theft, instead of the string of thefts that occurred. Investigators then may miss the patterns because data are not shared in consistent ways across departments. That means repeat offenders can keep operating under the radar, taking advantage of agencies that only see part of the story.

 

RTCCs and the Case for Regional Sharing

 

Real-time crime centers, or RTCCs, are becoming more common and offer a positive example of efforts to integrate otherwise siloed data. They aim to give departments a centralized view of what’s happening in their communities using live data from cameras, sensors and databases. When they work well, they’re powerful. But their effectiveness depends significantly on how much and what kind of data they can pull in. Many RTCCs are still limited by the same silos and vendor constraints. If they can’t see the full picture, including data from outside their jurisdiction, they can’t truly operate in real time.

 

The United States has about 18,000 law enforcement agencies. Each one has its own systems, contracts and policies. Building true interoperability will take more than just upgrading software. It requires a new mindset around regional data sharing.

 

That doesn’t mean everyone gets access to everything. It means building secure pathways for departments to connect data when there’s a lawful and necessary reason. It means setting common standards for how systems talk to one another. And it means designing tools that support privacy, accountability and local control from the start.

 

At ForceMetrics, we’re working with agencies to unify their own data across 911, crime reports, jail management and more into one platform that gives officers and leadership the context they need. Our goal isn’t just tech for tech’s sake. It’s about making sure responders have the right information to make better decisions in the field. But even the best tools can’t solve this alone. Agencies need to be willing to rethink how they manage and share their data. That’s a leadership challenge, not just a product one.

 

Public Safety Depends on Better Systems

 

At the end of the day, this isn’t about dashboards or data science. It’s about the decisions we make with the information we have or don’t have. If departments don’t have the full picture, they can’t make the best decisions. That affects everything from how resources are deployed to how communities are protected. We owe it to the public to fix this. We owe it to officers on the front lines. And we owe it to the people who fall through the cracks when the system doesn’t work.

 

We can’t keep pretending the data are fine just because they exist. We have to connect them, use them and truly make them count.


The contents of this Guest Column are those of the author, and not necessarily Barrett and Greene, Inc. 


#PublicSafetyDataManagement #PublicSafetyDataPerformance #StateandLocalPublicSafetyData #CityPoliceData #PoliceDataGovernance #StateandLocalDataGovernance #PublicSafetyDataLeadeship #PoliceDataUse #CityandCountyDataCompatibility #PoliceDataSiloes #PublicSafetyDataSiloes #ForceMetrics #RealTimeCrimeCenters #PublicSafetyDataInnovation #PoliceDataInteroperability #PublicSafetyDataCoordination #StateandLocalDataCoordination #PublicSafetyDataUse #PublicSafetyDataGovernance #DisconnectedPublicSafetyData #StateandLocalDataChallenge #PoliceDataChallenge #PoliceDataInteroperability #StateandLocalDataSharing #StateandLocalDataUse #StateandLocalDataPerforance #StreamliningPoliceData #PoliceCrossJurisdictionDataSharing #StateandLocalDataManagement #JacobCramer #BandGGuestColumn #BarrettandGreeneInc

 

GUEST COLUMN ARCHIVES

GUEST COLUMN ARCHIVES.
 

REWRITING PUBLIC PROCUREMENT RULES

READING THE SEISMOGRAPH OF GOVERNMENT DRIFT

DATA CENTERS: FINDING THE PERSUADABLE MIDDLE

YOUR TRAINING OFFICER IS NOT OVERHEAD

WHY TODAY’S EFFICIENCY PUSH COULD STALL IN THE STATES

HR: SOLUTIONS FOR A SYSTEM UNDER PRESSURE

GRANTMAKING: A POWERFUL GOVERNMENT TOOL

WHY US GOVERNMENTS SHOULD BENCHMARK THE WORLD

REWRITING THE PLAYBOOK ON PUBLIC WORKS RECRUITMENT

WHY COLLABORATION IS OUR COMPETETIVE ADVANTAGE

FOCUSING ON THE POSITIVE

Bridging the Academic/Practitioner Gap: Public Finance Journal

HUMAN SERVICES AS PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE

TRANSLATING PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT INTO ACTION

CIVIC ENGAGEMENT IN HIGHER EDUCATION

REFORMING PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION

WHEN THE DATA CHALLENGES YOU TO CHANGE

A COMPELLING SCORECARD FOR DEMOCRACY

SOCIAL MEDIA: BUILDING TRUST IN GOVERNMENT

MICHIGAN ROADMAP FOR REGULATORY EFFECTIVENESS

THE PAYOFFS TO PUBLIC SECTOR WORKFORCE INVESTMENT

FROM DATA AMBITION TO PUBLIC VALUE

INSPIRATIONAL WOMEN: THE FOOTPRINTS WE LEAVE

PERFORMANCE IN A TIME OF INSTABILITY

UNDERSTANDING MUNICIPAL FISCAL HEALTH

HOW AGENCY HEADS CAN FIX TRAINING

THINKING LIKE A COALITION DESIGNER

AI WEARINESS

THE MASSIVE PHYSICAL IMPACT OF DATA CENTERS

SPECIAL EDUCATION FUNDING: WHERE THE REAL RISK LIES

COUNTIES AND THE BIG SHIFT

CIVIL SERVICE MERIT VS EMPLOYMENT AT WILL

PLANNERS ARE PILLARS OF DEMOCRACY

HOW TO GET BETTER OUTCOMES IN EDUCATION

SMART SHORTCUTS FOR SMARTER BUDGETS

MEASURING SAFETY AND GETTING IT RIGHT

TIME TO MEET THE TRILLION-DOLLAR CHALLENGE

DEVALUING BLACK AND HISPANIC LATINA HOUSING IN CITIES

USING AUTOMATION TO INCREASE AUDIT PRODUCTIVITY

PUBLIC INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM FOR GOOD

A TALENT POOL FOR THE PUBLIC SECTOR

“EFFICIENCY IS NOT AN EXCUSE FOR PARALYSIS”

ART AND SCIENCE OF CREATING CONTRACTS

REFLECTIONS OF A RECENTLY DEPARTED HR DIRECTOR

“HAPPY EMPLOYEES: HAPPY RESIDENTS”

HOW TO TURN A STATE WORKFORCE INTO A TEAM

BUILDING RESILIENT TEAMS TO NAVIGATE UNCERTAINTY

BUILDING CAPACITY FOR CROSS-SECTOR COLLABORATION

GOVERNMENTAL MISTAKES THAT LIVE FOREVER

RESTORING PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN GOVERNMENT

WHAT DOES OVERSIGHT LEADERSHIP LOOK LIKE?

AFFORDABLE HOUSING: BUILDING A BRIGHTER FUTURE

RETHINKING THE MOTIVATION FOR AI

LET'S BE POSITIVE ABOUT GOVERNMENT AGAIN

THE DATA ILLUSION IN PUBLIC SAFETY

ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS AND THE HOUSING CRISIS

A ROUTE TO EXTREME WEATHER RESILIENCE

DECLINING TRUST UNDERMINES DEMOCRACY

FIVE WAYS TO GET READY FOR GENERATION ALPHA

AN OPEN BANKING PATH TO PUBLIC BENEFITS

IT DEPENDS ON WHAT YOU MEAN BY "EFFICIENCY"

HOW AI IS SHAPING DIGITAL ACCESSIBILITY

COST SAVINGS VS EFFICIENCY

NAVIGATING CHAOS

INVESTING IN COMMUNITY

HOW TO GET A LEGISLATOR TO LISTEN

HOW THE IOWA PIE PROGRAM IS SAVING TAXPAYER DOLLARS

HOW SHIFTING DEMOGRAPHICS ARE RESHAPING STATE FINANCES

A REMINISCENCE FROM R. KINNEY POYNTER

REPEAL OF THE MUNI-BOND TAX EXEMPTION WOULD THREATEN US INFRASTRUCTURE

ATTRACTING PUBLIC SERVICE LEADERS WHEN THE AXE HITS THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT

INSPIRATIONAL WOMEN IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT: HOPE IN POLARIZATION

FEDERAL JOB LOSSES EQUAL LOCAL OPPORTUNITIES

THREE ROUTES TO BETTER PROJECT MANAGEMENT

THE POWER OF UNITY

CUTBACK MANAGEMENT: STRATEGY, EVALUATION AND BLAME

BUILDING BROADBAND: THE VISION AND REAL WORLD

STATE BUDGETS: MANAGING EXPECTATIONS AS CONDITIONS RETURN TO NORMAL

HOW CAN LOCAL GOVERNMENTS IMPROVE HEALTH FOR OLDER AMERICANS?

THE AUDACITY OF NOPE

SUBVERSION AS A PUBLIC VALUE

HOW CAN WE PROVIDE ENOUGH EV CHARGERS?

PREPARING TODAY FOR RISING TIDES TOMORROW

A NOVEL REASON WHY GOVERNMENT CONSOLIDATIONS MIGHT MAKE SENSE

SUSTAINING DATA PRACTICES IN MAYORAL TRANSITIONS

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY IN TRANSITION

LESSONS FROM THE WESTERNS

IS YOUR GOVERNMENT PERFORMING BETTER THAN A YEAR AGO?

THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF PUBLIC LIBRARIES IN URBAN REVITALIZATION

STATE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY PERFORMANCE

THE HIGHER ED ROLE IN FILLING THE EMPLOYEE VOID

KEYS TO CONNECTING STATE GOVERNMENT AND PHILANTHROPY

NAVIGATING THE TECH LANDSCAPE: A GUIDE FOR GOVERNMENT

VIRGINIA’S DRIVE-TO-WORK PROGRAM IS A LIFELINE TO ECONOMIC SECURITY

DOES GETTING TOUGHER ON CRIME MAKE PEOPLE SAFER?

EQUITY: THE STATE OF THE STATES

WHAT MOTIVATES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO USE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT?

FEDERALISM IN 2025 AND BEYOND

IS THE FOUR-DAY WORKWEEK IN YOUR FUTURE?

HOW CAN AI MODERNIZE TAX ADMINISTRATION?

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management, inspirational women, sponsors, Privacy

 

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Managemen

SIGN UP FOR SPECIAL NEWS JUST FOR YOU.

Get exclusive subscriber-only links to news and articles and the latest information on this website sent directly in your inbox.

Thanks for Subscribing. You'll now recieve updates directly to your inbox.

Copyright @ Barrett and Greene, Inc.  |  All rights Reserved  |  Built By Boost  |  Privacy 212-684-5687  |  greenebarrett@gmail.com

bottom of page