top of page

Search Results

Search this site

403 results found with an empty search

  • IN DEFENSE OF THE BUREAUCRATS

    Over the course of the election season (which is, blessedly, over for a while), we repeatedly heard politicians insisting that the problem with government was bureaucracy. One example was Steve Hilton who was defeated in his race for governor of California. He was quoted by PBS as saying, “That spirit is being crushed by this bloated, nanny-state bureaucratic government. . .” This kind of talk reminded us of a B&G Report that we ran over 18 months ago, in which we pointed out that we disagreed strongly with the use of bureaucracy and bureaucrats as pejoratives. We quoted author Franz Kafka who once said, “Every revolution evaporates and leaves behind only the slime of a new bureaucracy.” But this kind of context for bureaucracy is a sad and frustrating fallacy. Without the bureaucrats, we’d be left with a bunch of policies and programs that would have no one left to implement them. There are, of course, stifling bureaucracies as well as efficient ones. But we take umbrage at the idea that the thousands of men and women who labor at getting the real work of government done are in league with the Devil of Small Details. With that in mind, at the time, we reached out to a bunch of smart people to see what they had to say about this issue. And now, because the timing seems right, we’re re-playing their quotes: William Hatcher, Chair and Professor, Department of Social Sciences, Augusta University: “Few words invoke such negative mental images as ‘bureaucracy.’ When the public hears the word, they envision overly complex processes that lack empathy. They envision careless bureaucrats, more concerned about procedures than public service. As we in public administration know, these images are distorted and not reality. Bureaucracies and the bureaucrats occupying them are needed to ensure that our communities have the public goods to survive and prosper. Only through organizing into bureaucracies can we try to solve the problems facing our communities. Thus, bureaucracies are beyond a necessary evil, and we in public administration need to, as Charles Goodsell so soundly argued, make the case for bureaucracies.” Michael Jacobson, former director for performance and strategy in King County's Office of Performance, Strategy and Budget: “I am a proud bureaucrat. But not in the popularized sense of a mindless and faceless paper-pushing, behind-the-scenes employee of government that doesn’t care about residents or customers. I mean in the sense of someone whose role was codified to counter the overly politicized, corrupt personal favoritism of the Tammany Hall period – someone who is there to, at least in principle, ensure that fair, and more recently equitable, treatment is foremost, and (that) the effective administration of my job is not subject to the personal whim of an individual behind a desk or computer screen. “I am using bureaucrat in the sense of a highly competent professional who has organizational savvy to get things done in a large and complex organization; someone with technical skills, management wherewithal, and personal knowledge of the organization who is able to follow procedures, and at times, question those same procedures. Without these kinds of bureaucrats, things don’t get done; or we go back to corruption and personal power alone as the way to get the organization to produce.” William Brantley, author of “The Persuasive Project Manager: Communicating For Understanding”: “Bureaucracies, though often seen as rigid, can be agile with adaptive structures and a culture of improvement. Agility comes from decentralizing decisions, investing in workforce training, and integrating feedback loops for real-time learning. Lean management, digital transformation, and cross-functional teams can streamline processes and reduce delays while maintaining stability and accountability. When leadership prioritizes responsiveness and innovation, alongside transparency and equity, bureaucracies can adapt to new challenges and societal needs." Don Kettl, professor emeritus, University of Maryland: “It’s become truly unfortunate that 'bureaucracy' has become a pejorative—or, even worse, a curse word to attack government, with critics almost spitting it as a form of criticism. It doesn’t make much sense to remind everyone that “bureaucracy” is simply a word used to describe a way of structuring complex organizations—or that private organizations are “bureaucracies” as well. By extension, a “bureaucrat” ought to be a simple, clear, and neutral way of describing someone who works for a large and complex organization. Alas, that’s not the case. “So, we seem to face a choice. We probably can’t talk people out of using 'bureaucracy' as a pejorative, or to characterize 'bureaucracy' as anything but a pejorative, no matter how hard we try. We can just swallow the problem and try to move on, or we can choose a word that has not built up such animosity around us.” Andrew Kleine, Senior Director, Government & Public Sector at EY. “Without bureaucracy, there’s no democracy. Bureaucrats carry out the will of the people by running police departments, processing food stamp applications, inspecting restaurant kitchens, fixing broken water pipes, and so much more. It is hard to imagine a world with no people and organizations employed to implement and enforce laws, ordinances and codes. Even the Wild West had sheriffs!” #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalGovernance #StateandLocalGovernmentPerformnace #CityPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #InDefenseOfBureaucracy #MidTermElectionRhetoric #BadmouthingGovernmentBureaucracy#NecessityOfBureaucrats #CountyGovernmentManagement #CountyPerformance #StateandLocalPublicAdministration #StateandLocalPolicyImplementation #PraiseForGovernmentBureaucrats #StateandLocalGovernmentAccountability #StateandLocalGovernmentTransparency #InDefenseOfBureaucrats#StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #PublicServiceAndPublicBureaucrats #CityPublicAdministration #CountyPublicAdministration #BureaucratsAndOrganizationalSavvy #DonKettl #AndrewKleine #MichaelJacobson #WilliamHatcher #WilliamBrantley #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • WHAT NOT TO DO IN HARD TIMES

    The future of state and local budgets is never entirely clear, but as things stand right now, it appears as though we’re heading for a time when there may need to be a lot of belt-tightening. There are a handful of ways that many entities approach shortfalls of cash, including cutting back on services and raising taxes. But neither is particularly popular for residents who aren’t entirely clear about the pain that budget offices face in trying to construct a balanced budget. People tend to be happy with service cuts, as long as they’re not the services they use themselves. And nobody much likes higher taxes. With that in mind, many states, cities and counties find their way to other routes to a semblance of fiscal security. Sadly, while most of these may be short-term fixes, in the long term, they’re going to take their toll. Take training. Though many places are currently focused on employee development, slashing training is a very easy thing to do. This approach goes entirely unnoticed by residents. What’s more, a reduction of training adds back time that state and local government managers are often reluctant to give away. We’re not only talking about traditional training offered in the workplace, but the kind of knowledge that employees can gain when they attend out-of-state conferences. We go to many of these and can see the new information that is imparted. In addition to the ideas communicated in formal sessions, are the benefits that come when attendees are at receptions, dining together and chatting in the hallways. We’re not aware of many entities that are issuing blanket prohibitions on out-of-state travel, but it’s easy to place administrative hurdles that are intended to suppress the likelihood that employees will sign up to attend these gatherings. One way that this can happen is when the permissions necessary for travel are lifted up the food chain from department directors to higher levels – putting a lid on the desire to even ask. An even less effective way to save cash is deferring preventive maintenance on government assets. For example, delaying road and bridge repairs eventually results in one of two options: close down the road or bridge entirely (which is rarely feasible) or spend a great deal more money for repairs when they can no longer be ignored. In April, KIRO radio in Washington reported that “The Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) had to shut down two lanes of the westbound bridge, built 76 years ago, after an inspection earlier this week found severe damage to the steel supporting the bridge’s right side.” The news story went on to explain that “The legislature routinely shortchanges the maintenance and preservation budget by nearly $1 billion a year, choosing to spend scarce transportation dollars elsewhere. It has done this for decades, so it’s no coincidence that our aging infrastructure is failing.” And it’s not just roads and bridges. Buildings need to be maintained on a regular basis, or they’ll wind up decaying as time goes by. The results of avoiding regular roof maintenance can lead to leaks, which can destroy other assets, thus multiplying the costs many times over. Both the lack of training and deferred maintenance are unfortunate ways to keep a budget in balance. Yet another ill-advised action occurs on the revenue side. To avoid tax increases many entities turn to bringing in cash through fees and fines. There are certainly instances in which fees and fines are legitimate sources of revenue. It’s hard to argue with the idea that people should pay for the use of a municipal golf course. And parking tickets can not only bring in dollars, they help downtown merchants make sure there are spaces reasonably close to them for new customers. But even these can be abusive means of bringing in dollars. Some entities turn over the collection of fines for tickets, which adds late fees or interest when someone misses a deadline. Over time that can turn a rational $75 ticket into an unpayable thousand-dollar debt. In almost all cases, fines and fees are a regressive source of revenue. As the Urban Institute wrote in an October 2025 paper, “Criminal legal system fines and fees are a routine source of revenue for many state and local governments. These legal financial obligations encompass both penalties imposed for civil infractions, such as traffic and parking tickets, and court- or incarceration-related costs. Recent federal policies may increase pressure on states and localities to fill budget gaps and consider options for raising additional revenue. However, expanding reliance on fines and fees may deepen financial hardships among residents without meaningfully improving state and local budgets. . . “Nearly one in five working-age adults reported their households were charged fines or fees in 2024, with court and incarceration-related costs disproportionately affecting families with low incomes." We sympathize with the troubles many entities face when expenditures appear to be outstripping revenues. But we’d argue that biting the bullet and raising taxes or diminishing services may be necessary. It’s not easy. But nobody ever said that the work of government was supposed to be easy. #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalGovernmentBudgeting #BalancingStateandLocalBudgets #StateandLocalFinancialManagement #StateandLocalRevenueShortfalls #StateandLocalStructuralImbalance #StateShortTermBudgetCutsWithLongTermConsequences #CityShortTermBudgetCutsWithLongTermConsequences #CountyShortTermBudgetCutsWithLongTermConsequences #StateandLocalPreventiveMaintenace #CityGovernmentBudgeting #CountyGovernmentBudgeting #StateandLocalPreventiveMaintenance #ShortsightedCutsToRoadMaintenance #ShortsightedCutsToBuildingMaintenance #StateandLocalEmployeeDevelopment #StateandLocalEmployeeTraining #StateandLocalTrainingCutbacks #StateandLocalMaintenanceCutbacks #FineAndFeeRegressivity #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • BOARDING UP BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS

    Cities, counties and states are full of a variety of boards and commissions, many of which play a vital role in the smooth running of government. Sadly, over the course of time, some of these bodies fall into disuse and disarray. In many cases, meetings are cancelled with regularity, which can turn into a kind of vicious cycle in which board members don’t take schedules seriously, and are more inclined to miss even those that take place. What’s more, even commissions that exist in little more than name can drain an entity of resources, including money, staff energy, initial participant enthusiasm and time. Consider this January 2026 analysis from San Franciso’s Commission Streamlining Task Force, “San Francisco’s commission system includes 152 boards and commissions, made up of over one thousand residents who volunteer their time to shape their government, reflecting the City’s commitment to civic engagement and political activism. At its best, the system helps ensure that San Francisco’s government remains transparent, accountable, and reflective of the diverse communities it serves. However, many bodies have existed for decades without evaluation of their efficacy. Some are defunct, duplicative, or have outlived their useful purpose.” With that in mind, the task force recommended “combining or eliminating certain bodies to reduce the total number of commission seats from approximately 1,500 to 900,” on a staggered basis. According to a February article in SF Gate, the task force’s final report noted that "At its worst, the commission system adds layers of bureaucracy that dilute public input, obscure lines of accountability, make government less transparent, and result in duplicative or ineffective processes." About a year ago The Louisiana Legislative Auditor explored the status of its 489 boards and identified “19 inactive Boards that do not appear to be fulfilling their established functions. Fifteen of these inactive Boards were also identified as inactive in the prior year.” Worse yet, “We identified 37 Boards that reported their status as active but have not reported any meeting notices or minutes subsequent to December 31, 2021. Also, 11 of these Boards have no board members identified on the website.” Even when boards or commissions are functional, there are many instances in which they are little more than generators of information or reports that are ignored by anyone with the power to turn them into action. Just a few weeks ago, the Oakland, California City auditor reported that “City staff capacity was the top concern cited by both board members and staff liaisons. Members expressed uncertainty about their board’s influence over City decision-making, with 33 percent of members characterizing their board’s relationship with the City Council as ‘weak’ or ‘very weak,’ compared to 17 percent saying ‘strong’ or ‘very strong.’ Many members identified unclear board duties and goals as a factor inhibiting boards from running effectively. Members and staff also cited difficulties accessing information pertinent to carrying out their board’s duties.” Ineffective or unproductive boards and commissions come with costs. In fact, cities, counties and states that allow them to continue end up establishing staff liaisons, which consume time and effort that would otherwise be used for more productive activities. Fortunately, there are steps that entities can take to try to cut down on boards and commissions that aren’t producing productive results by sunsetting them. Miami-Dade County, for example. has a statute that eases the way to eliminate boards through the chairperson of the board of county commissioners who may “may evaluate County boards, based on the County Mayor's recommendations and any other information that the Chairperson deems relevant, to determine whether each board shall continue in its present form,” or a be abolished consolidated or modified according to the law. A number of factors can be taken into account, which the county spells out. These include questions about whether the board is serving the purpose for which it was created; whether the board is serving current community needs: whether there is any other board, either public or private, which would better serve the function of the board. Another consideration is the cost, both direct and indirect of maintaining the board. Austin, Texas established something similar on December 12, 2024, which directed its city manager to take a close look at its inventory of current boards, commissions, task forces and other groups that had been established and to work with the city clerk to create a regular sunset review process, explained a June 15 memorandum from the city’s chief of staff. As a result, entities that have been disbanded, include the Austin Local Solar Advisory Committee; Airport Boulevard Advisory Group; the Regional Affordability Committee; the Austin Industrial Development Corporation and more. Of course, it’s not always easy to eliminate boards and commissions, as well as advisory bodies, which have been established for a clear purpose. When residents believe that a particular body is representing their interests – whether or not it’s effective or necessary, there’s always a chance that they will protest its consolidation or elimination. That’s why we’d argue that taking these steps must be a very transparent process explaining exactly why the actions were justified. #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalPerformance #StateandLocalBoardAndCommisionManagement #IneffectiveStateBoardsAndCommissions #IneffectiveCityBoardsAndCommissions #IneffectiveCountyBoardsAndCommissions #StateBoardandCommissionManagement #CityBoardandCommissionManagement #CountyBoardandCommissionManagement #StateBoardandCommissionPerformance #CityBoardandCommissionPerformance #CountyBoardandCommissionPerformance #StateandLocalPerformanceAudit #CityPerformanceAudit #CountyPerformanceAudit #OaklandCityAuditor #SolutionsForIneffectiveBoardsAndCommissions #MiamiDadeCountyBoardandCommissionStatutoryApproach #OaklandBoardAndCommissionsAuditReport #AustinBoardAndCommissionSunsetReview #SanFranciscoCommissionStreamliningTaskForce #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • PUBLIC SECTOR AMNESIA

    As a growing number of state and local employees are heading toward retirement, the conversation generally focuses on how to retain them or how to recruit their replacements. Both are certainly important questions, but they leave out a critical issue that confronts entities from coast to coast: The loss of institutional memory. From our vantage point, covering state and local government for decades, it repeatedly comes as a surprise to us when we interview someone in a reasonably high position whose knowledge of what has gone on in earlier years is lacking. Not long ago, for example, we were talking with an official in a big city who was proud of the fact that his office was – for the very first time – engaging in an initiative to bring performance management techniques to his community. At risk of being snarky, we pointed out that, even though he thought this was the first time his city was entering this territory, the truth lies elsewhere. In fact, decades ago, we had publicly praised the city for great work in the identical realm. But after that effort was drastically diminished, the fact that it ever existed had been lost in the mists of time. When memories are left to die as people leave government service, it’s a significant loss. There are many lessons that can be learned from successes of the past, as well as failures. When an effort was put forth at some time in the past, and it crumbled, it’s easy to make the same mistakes once again. Though there may be various kinds of knowledge transfer that occur informally, according to research done by MissionSquare only 29% of communities it covered in a survey, had “planning/documentation for institutional knowledge transfer.” (See page 33) There are many issues that crop up when important information isn’t handed off. As Shernica Ferguson, Evaluation Specialist, Public Policy and Administration, at Jackson State University wrote in National Civic Review, “Without experienced staff who understand the historical logic behind existing protocols, new employees inherit a tangle of accumulated decisions that look arbitrary.” It’s not easy to commit to the transmission of knowledge across work generations. For one thing, there are many factors involved in performing the tasks necessary to smoothly run a city, county or state. Some of them are written down in manuals or guides. But many others aren’t ever really recognized in a formal way, and when people do their jobs well, they often utilize information that they’d never even think about passing along. One solution here is to share that kind of instinctive information by encouraging newer employees to work alongside old hands. In that way they can pick up the knowledge they’re going to need some day. There are, of course, other solutions, too, and we’re encouraged to see examples of governments that formally encourage information transfusion. For example, The state of South Carolina’s Department of Administration publishes a “Knowledge Management Guide.” It acknowledges the difficulties in this discipline – including lack of time and resources – and includes some relatively easy approaches for agencies. One of the easiest of all, mentioned in the Guide, is simply telling stories. “While storytelling can easily be dismissed because it may sound silly, it is one of the most robust, and easiest to implement, knowledge sharing techniques there is. Imagine the depth of knowledge gained from having your employees share the lessons learned from a real-life scenario experienced by the storyteller. Debriefing, case studies, after action reviews, whatever you want to call it, the knowledge gained and shared through storytelling is extensive. Employees may also find it easier to understand information presented in the form of a story rather than a bulleted list of facts.” Meanwhile, New Jersey is using artificial intelligence to retain important information. As we wrote in a blog post for the IBM Center for the Business of Government, New Jersey’s Department of Community Affairs has developed a program “called “Ask Claudia.” This is a tool that case managers have the option to use that replicates the knowledge of a real department employee named Claudia, who is close to retirement from state service and has accumulated a wealth of knowledge that can be used by others in the department. This generative AI tool accomplishes this through knowledge transfer input she has provided and through its ability to scan regulations and policies that help Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program employees in accurately answering questions that come from the public.” South Carolina and New Jersey aren’t alone in emphasizing knowledge transfer, but it’s far from common. And that’s unfortunate. We were particularly fond of a June 9 blog post by Rick Barry, Director of Operations for Satellite Locations and Admin Services at NorthWest Arkansas Community College who spelled out the sad series of steps involved when a department doesn’t adequately educate the next generation with the knowledge their predecessors had. Here they are: The Departure: A key veteran leaves suddenly, taking decades of "tacit knowledge"—the unwritten context of city operations—with them. The Scramble: Junior staff try to fill the gap but lack the "soft knowledge" (the why behind the what), leading to inconsistent decision-making. The Service Lag: Permit review times slow down and public complaints increase as projects stall. Turnover Contagion: The added stress and "operational drag" cause mid-career "bridge" employees to seek remote roles in the private sector. Institutional Amnesia: The department is now staffed entirely by new hires with no connection to the city's historical policies or community relationships. #StateandLocalKnowledgeTransfer #StateKnowledgeTransfer #CityKnowledgeTransfer #CountyKnowledgeTransfer #PublicSectorAmnesia #StateandLocalGovernmentHumanResources #StateandLocalGovernmentHR #CityHumanResources #CountyHumanResources #StateandLocalManagement #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalEmployeeRetirement #StateandLocalEmployeeRetention #PublicSectorInstitutionalMemoryLoss #MissionSquareResearchInstitute #ShernicaFerguson #JacksonStateUniversity #NationalCivicReview #SouthCarolinaKnowledgeManagementGuide #StateandLocalStoryTelling #PublicSectorStoryTelling #OrganizationalAmnesia #SouthCarolinaDepartmentOfAdministration #KnowledgeTransferAndArtificialIntelligence #StateandLocalGovernmentGenerativeAIPolicyandManagement #StateandLocalArtificialIntelligence #StateandLocalGenerativeAIAndKnowledgeTransfer #IBMCenterBusinessOfGovernment #NewJerseyDepartmentCommunityAffairs #AskClaudia #RickBarryBlogPost #NorthWestArkansasCommunityCollege #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • THE SAD WORLD OF UNDERFUNDING

    It’s fulfilling for governmental leaders to come up with good notions for new programs or infrastructure designed to make life better for the citizenry. And from our perspective, it’s a lot of fun to write about them – often when they’re just out of the pilot stage. Unfortunately, in all too many cases, even the best ideas go begging for enough operating cash to fulfill their promise. We first became aware of this phenomenon many years ago, when we wrote about counties and states that were building prisons to alleviate overcrowding. Pretty soon, problems began to crop up for entities that hadn’t appropriately considered the operating expenses required to put people inside. One famous case was the Wapato Detention Facility in Multnomah County, Oregon, which was funded by a bond issue. It cost $58 million, but the county never came up with the money to operate the facility. While it was finished in 2004, it was never opened as a detention facility and wound up in the hands of a couple of developers, with a price tag that was ultimately around $5 million. In October 2020, it was turned into the Bybee Lakes Hope Center, aimed at building “self-sufficiency and skills to transition to life after homelessness,” as described in a Portland.gov website We haven’t seen something as dramatic as the Wapato Detention tale in recent years, but the failure to consider operating expenses is still an issue worthy of note. Consider, for example, the police departments, school districts and transit agencies that are accumulating unfathomable amounts of digital video and surveillance data every year. Much of this massive footage is emblematic of the tree that falls in a forest, and nobody hears. Stockpiling film by itself is pretty much worthless unless money is set aside to provide review personnel, redaction, and storage infrastructure that’s necessary to use this material lawfully. The result: city attorney offices and clerks face huge backlogs, long missed deadlines and expensive litigation. There are also instances in which governments spend money unproductively because they’ve chosen not to make upfront investments that would benefit residents. Consider unproductive and vacant parcels of land which belong to the city after the owners fail to pay their taxes. When governments bypass efforts to develop the land, they still need to devote public dollars to at least minimal maintenance. If they don’t, vacant parcels can become eyesores that accrue garbage, rat infestations and dead trees, which require pruning to keep branches from crashing into the street in a storm. Unfortunately, public works departments often lack budgets to take care of these properties and the opportunity to repurpose them is passed by for lack of the money to do so. Deferred maintenance provides another significant example of how underfunding can have long-term impact on roads, bridges, buildings, parks and other public assets. While the initial announcement provides excitement, positive attention fades over time if funding for maintenance is left out. In fact, every time budgeters put off spending cash on regular maintenance, they’re making the decision to spend more money later. If a road can be resurfaced this year, that will help put off the possibility of having to rebuild the road entirely in years to come. Worse yet, many places don’t even keep good track of what they should be spending in any given year. As the Pew Charitable Trusts wrote in late 2025, “The true costs of deferred maintenance—the accumulated gap between what should have been invested to preserve, maintain, and repair public infrastructure and what was actually spent—are difficult to determine because most states don’t consistently define, measure, or report deferred maintenance in their budgets or capital planning documents. And without clear data, policymakers lack the necessary information to understand how current policies might fall short.” One last example of this phenomenon comes in the significant investments that entities can make in brand new technologies (notably AI in recent years). Over the years, we’ve repeatedly witnessed the vulnerability of training funds, especially when budgets grow tighter. Ensuring consistent funding for training is needed to ensure that technology investments genuinely pay off The ramifications of underfunded training aren’t immediately obvious internally and are pretty much invisible to the general population. But leaving employees without appropriate education inevitably means that the benefits of the initial investments will be less than they could have been. We’d like to offer up a call to action for state and local officials: If you make an investment of any kind be certain that you can truly make it pay off, even though that will cost more dollars on an ongoing basis. #StateandLocalGovernmentBudgeting #CityGovernmentBudgeting #CountyGovernmentBudgeting #StateandLocalLongTermPlanning #CityLongTermPlanning #CountyLongTermPlanning #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #CityGovernmentManagement #CountyGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #CityPerformanceManagement #CountyPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalUnderfundedOperatingCosts #CityUnderfundedOperatingCosts #CountyUnderfundedOperatingCosts #StateandLocalUnderfundedMaintenance #CityUnderfundedMaintenance #CountyUnderfundedMaintenance #StateandLocalUnderfundedPrisonOperatingCosts #CountyUnderfundedPrisonOperatingCosts #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • THE STORY BEHIND THE DATA

    Cities, counties and states are overladen with data, and with the advent of AI, it’s likely that the current flood will be turning into a tsunami. But we’re often dismayed when we speak with people in these entities only to discover that they can spout out plenty of numbers, but they can’t really understand the story behind them. At a recent conference, for example, one of the speakers showed an alarming slide that demonstrated that a particular city had a disproportionate amount of crime. We asked if he could explain why this was the case, and it turned out that though he could show us all the numbers, he couldn’t explain the “why” behind them. (Side note: When we searched the Internet about this particular episode, we discovered that the data we’d seen was a couple of years old, and they’d improved dramatically since.) We understand the value of purely quantitative data and we know that many academics take a qualitative approach, as well. But when one exists without the other, there's something missing. Now, let’s go back to one of the highlights of our career, which we believe can be an example of the way we’d like data to work. It was called the Government Performance Project (GPP), and it was funded by the Pew Charitable Trusts, and published in Governing Magazine between 1998 and 2008. The goal was to evaluate the management capacity of the nation’s states on a regular basis in such important fields as human resources, performance management, information technology, infrastructure and budgeting. On other occasions, the same project involved large cities and counties. For each of these multiple projects, we had two teams of researchers -- one of which was made of university professors and graduate students and the other made of journalists. Together, we developed a number of criteria and sub-criteria in order to make our evaluations. The academics and grad students culled carefully through a lengthy survey instrument which was developed with the full team. With just a few exceptions each year, we received all but a few surveys back. (This wasn’t easy, by the way, and we regularly had to make the point to reticent governments that they could choose not to cooperate, but they couldn’t opt out of the evaluation and filling out the survey provided their best chance of the GPP getting their story right.) Our academic partners studied the answers and translated the responses many of the answers into numeric format which could be used to yield a grade for all the major fields we were examining. Simultaneously, the journalistic team, which we headed up, read the surveys and did hundreds of interviews with leaders and external observers in the governments and pursued each of the criteria and sub-criteria through lengthy interviews. The team of interviewers then took their best stab at using the information to evaluate what they garnered through these conversations. When the journalists and the academics didn’t come to the same conclusion, we researched further, discussed the issues, and came to a final decision. The point of this self-serving reminiscence is that without the interviews, it was easy for the pure data to lead to incorrect assumptions. Meanwhile, the academic approach made the whole process far more rigorous and helped to catch issues that come up in interviews (for example, people trying to put a happy face on a bad situation). This exercise was hugely successful, and it was remarkable how few governments disagreed with our conclusions – even when they were negative. The major issue some had was with the criteria we were using in the first place. But the project was careful to make the criteria clear. This was a very time-consuming and expensive multi-year effort and we understand that without the support of an organization like Pew it wouldn’t have been possible. But, still it was an experience that leads us to believe that without actually digging deeper into the gritty numbers, there’s every chance that they may be misleading for any number of reasons. Consider this hypothetical example: A city agency carefully measures processing times for permits, and comes up with data that show its efforts cut the time to process a permit by 40%. By itself, the city and analysts can declare victory, and boast about it to all concerned. But interviews with people involved may uncover the notion that the entity was short-changing the proper amount of effort to make sure a permit was genuinely deserved. As a result the positive data may be hiding flaws in the system that are of significance. Of course, when conclusions are reached purely through conversations, that’s far from perfect, too. We’ve also come across papers and articles that are based exclusively on a handful of interviews. When there are hundreds of them, and care is taken to make sure the interviewees represent a cross section of the population being studied, that can work out pretty well. But we’ve seen too many instances when only a small handful or people were involved. Ultimately, if a major study or a report is published, we’d like to see that it’s based on a combination of carefully gathered data and journalistic interviews to put it in context. To be perfectly honest, resources -- both time and money -- make the capacity to do as huge a project as this difficult, but a collaborative approach still provides a great model for telling the story behind the data. #StateandLocalManagement #StateandLocalGovermentPerformance #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #GovernmentPerformanceProject #PewCharitableTrusts #GoverningMagazine #GradingTheStates #GradingTheCities #GradingTheCounties #StateandLocalManagementRanking #StateManagementEvaluation #StateandLocalHRManagement #StateandLocalInformationTechnologyManagement #StateandLocalGovernmentBudgeting #StateandLocalInfrastructureManagement #JournalistAcademicCollaboration #StateandLocalPerformanceManagementEvaluation #StateandLocalSurveyResearch #StateandLocalPerformanceMeasurement #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • EIGHT TIPS FOR CONFERENCE PRESENTERS

    We’ve been on the road a lot lately attending conferences around the country. The primary benefit we get from these sessions are the conversations we have in the hallways and receptions, as well as meeting new sources we can use to feed our insatiable need for content for this website. But of course, we also attend scads of concurrent sessions and plenary speeches, as well. And often they are captivating and even inspirational. In fact, just a couple of weeks ago, we published a management update about a plenary speech we heard from Mary Guy, University of Colorado Distinguished Professor, and past President of the American Society for Public Administration, that was given at the joint Southeastern Conference on Public Administration (SECOPA) and Northeast Conference on Public Administration (NECOPA) in Norfolk, Virginia. It was a great talk, focused on the critical nature of public administration work and the role of everyone at the conference in turning the “wheels of democracy.” That said, more often than we’d like, we find ourselves frustrated by conference speeches and sessions which have inviting titles, but don’t really bring us any news that we can use or that satiates our curiosity about an important topic. While our biases about what makes good and bad sessions may not be true of everyone, we believe they’re generally reasonable. So, here are a handful of our recommendations for anyone contemplating a stint as moderator or presenter at a future public sector conference. 1) Avoid unreadable slides. We can’t really understand why anyone puts up slides in which the type is so tiny that nobody – even in a small room – can possibly see the numbers and the words which are often pointed out by the speaker with a computer cursor on the screen. It’s understandable that data on these slides may be the culmination of months or years of work. But when they’re unreadable, they become a distraction that sets us to speculating about what session we’ll be attending next. 2) While we’re talking about slides, even when they’re readable, we’d suggest that speakers avoid the temptation to read verbatim from them. Not to be snarky, but if everything in a presentation is already on the slides, we’d be just as happy getting a copy to read ourselves. We know, of course, that an actual live session provides the opportunity to ask questions and that often adds value, but that leads to our item number 3. 3) There’s often a promise made by a speaker or a moderator of a panel that there’ll be time for Q&A at the end of the session. But in a remarkable number of instances, the speakers go on longer than anticipated and so there’s no time for questions or room for only one or two at most. We’ve moderated enough panels to know that it’s tough for moderators to get a long-winded speaker to wind down. But we recommend emphasizing as strongly as possible the importance of keeping to schedule. 4) If someone makes a comment instead of asking a question, this is a great opportunity for a moderator to turn the comment into a query for a panel. There are often lots of smart people in the audience with good things to say, but most of the people in the room are there to hear the thoughts of the people on the stage. Moderators could do a service to audience and presenters by giving the latter a chance to add on. 5) Concrete examples in presentations are the cherries on top of the ice cream. Even when the topic is heavily academic, providing actual examples that support findings make talks more engaging. Hypothetical examples are good. Real-world examples are even better. 6) Most often, speakers are provided with microphones, but we find that many forget that when they turn to look at a slide or let a hand-held mike drift away from their mouths, they can’t be heard. In addition, it’s often hard, even in a small room, for the audience to hear questions that come from their fellow session attendees. That’s why we wish it were standard practice for presenters or moderators to repeat a question that may be minimally audible before answering it. 7) If you’re on a panel and another panelist is talking, listen, react and, at least, appear to be engaged. In webinars and at conferences, we worry when panelists look distracted or even bored when fellow guests speak. If audience members get the impression that the panelists aren’t interested in one another, they’re less inclined to be interested themselves. 8) One more note about slides. If they are full of formulas that are perfectly comprehensible to some attendees, it’s likely that they’ll be unfathomable to many others. It might be worthwhile asking the audience if they are capable of making sense of the equations, before going into them in depth. And if many aren’t, then get right to the conclusions, and leave out the formulaic methodology. #StateandLocalGovernmentConferences #TipsForConferencePresenters #StateandLoalAcademicPractitionerCommunication #StateandLocalPublicAdministration #PublicSectorConferences #AdviceForStateAndLocalConferenceModerators #AdviceForStateAndLocalConferencePresenters #AdviceForPublicSectorConferencePanelists #StateandLocalConferencePresentations #StateandLocalGovernment #CityGovernment #CountyGovernment #BarrettandGreeneConferenceTips #MaryGuy #SECOPA #NECOPA #AmericanSocietyForPublicAdministration #ASPA #BandGReport #BandGReportRecommendations #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • THE ACADEMIC-PRACTITIONER GAP

    One of the goals we have for our website content is to give academics the opportunity to communicate their significant findings with practitioners. We’re rather zealous about this, because we see the gap between the work that comes from universities and their actual use in the public sector as one of the biggest missed opportunities for governments. So, for example, in just the last months, we’ve featured Guest Columns from professors at Kean University, Augusta University, University of Nebraska, California State University and more. Additionally, we feature Management Updates that highlight studies and reports that come from academics practically every week or so. Obviously, as much as we try, we’re a tiny bit of linkage between the two groups and the disconnect is extremely large. We don’t believe that government officials genuinely want to eschew the work of academics. But there are dramatically different incentives, timelines and ways of communicating that stand in the way of working together for the benefit of all. For one thing, universities tend to reward faculty members for getting published in lengthy, well researched journal articles. These simply aren’t the kind of thing that practitioners read – and even if they tried to do so, these publications are expensive for individuals without a university connection. What’s more, the articles are often long and complex. The abstracts that are available are limited and even when article access is possible, only a handful of public sector employees (including legislative staff) have the time to read through them. What’s more, many academic papers don’t make an effort to boil their findings down into the kind of practical useable guidance that practitioners need to deal with the seemingly endless litany of problems they’re trying to solve. Then there’s an unfortunate mismatch in timing. Truly rigorous academic papers can easily take years to complete, and many of them are based on data that is remarkably out of date. We frequently find ourselves unable to use the conclusions reached in academic literature when we discover that the information upon which it’s based is years or even decades old. One of the issues we run across most frequently is the fact that peer-reviewed literature is (in the words of a long-time friend) “gritty with numbers.” They’re full of regression tables. We know what regression tables are supposed to accomplish, but we can’t really understand many of them, and we don’t think it’s presumptuous to assume that the folks who make cities, counties and states function well, don’t understand them either. This is often driven home to us when we attend conferences in which many of the presenters are academics who are interested in getting attention for their work. But when the slides that pop up on the screen are full of formulas, we have to force ourselves to be polite and not sidle out of the room. Even the writing style is an obstacle to comprehensibility. Paragraphs run on until readers’ eyes grow bleary. Jargon and acronyms are everywhere. In collaboration with the highly-esteemed academic Don Kettl (who is exceptional in his ability to write in prose that can be comprehended), we wrote a book in 2024 titled “The Little Guide to Writing for Impact.” Our fantasy was that this would help academics reach out to practitioners in approachable language that keeps people wanting to move forward to the next paragraph. We know we’re hardly alone in wanting to see the practitioner-academic link strengthened. Several years ago, we wrote about an executive branch initiative in North Carolina that actively connected state researchers with academics at colleges and universities (and with links to foundations, as well). Sadly, the North Carolina model didn’t live past the change in the gubernatorial administration. There may be failures to communicate on the academic side, but it’s not clear to us that states and localities are clamoring for more great ideas generated by institutions of higher learning. At least they don’t seem willing to spend the cash in order to smooth this process. If they really wanted, they could hire dedicated policy analysts trained as academic-to-practitioner-translators. We haven’t become aware of any positions like that. If readers of this column are aware of promising efforts to close the academic-practitioner gap, please let us know. We’d be happy to give them some publicity. #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalGovernmentPerformance #CityGovernmentManagement #AcademicGovernmentCommunicationsGap #AcademicImpactOnLocalGovernment #AcademicImpactOnStateGovernment #StateandLocalGovernmentResearch #PublicSectorHigherEducationResearchLink #GovernmentAcademicCommunication #ImprovingResearchPartnerships #OptimizingGovernmentResearchNeeds #CityGovernmentResearchNeeds #CountyGovernmentResearchNeeds #StateandLocalGovernmentResearchNeeds #CityGovernmentResearchNeeds #ApplyingAcademicResearchToPolicy #AcademicGovernmentResearchGap #B&GReport #DonaldFKettl #NorthCarolinaOfficeOfStrategicPartnerships #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • THE MISSING REAR VIEW MIRROR

    As readers of this website know, we’re always on the lookout for exciting new programs and policies in state and local government. There are plenty of them out there. Not only do they provide fodder for this space, but we’re always pleased to share them with our friends, many of whom have come to believe that nothing good is happening in government today. But here’s our problem. After some time passes and we want to refer again to our original discovery, it’s often the case that we can’t find out what’s happened to it. Was it a success? A failure? Someplace in between? Consider new technological innovations. There’s often lots of excitement in a city, county or state that has invested lots of money in a high-tech solution designed to save time and effort. But when we check back months or even years later, we don’t find much reporting on the performance gains (or losses) that have followed the investment. While there are often articles that focus on the time and budget hurdles confronted during development and implementation, there's not so much about the results. From an elected official’s point of view, this is somewhat understandable – even if it’s not good for the public. After all, big announcements about a new economic development approach or a promising efficiency initiative can draw lots of attention from voters and perhaps even help garner votes when election time rolls around. But evaluating these efforts down the line runs the risk that they won’t have panned out. Tracking down the end of the story is a powerful tool for the government in charge, and a laudable approach to improving the use of taxpayer dollars. But this information is also a weapon for opponents to use in a fight to demonstrate the incompetence of the current administration. There’s an old maxim that “honesty is the best policy,” but it has its cost. Beyond that, even when there are follow up evaluations, there’s rarely any commentary about the big “but for” question. It’s easy to claim that a new program has made real progress, but it’s understandably difficult to answer the question of what would have happened if the investment hadn’t been made. This is hardly a new issue. In fact, the Pew Charitable Trusts set forth this example in a 2018 issue brief: “Consider a state that implements a summer program to help students who are reading below grade level. Performance data shows that participants scored significantly higher on English language arts exams than students who were similarly struggling to read at grade level but did not participate in the program. “Is the summer reading program the reason the test scores went up? More important for state policy makers, is this a program the state should expand to improve students learning?” Another issue is that it’s rarely the case that one government’s effort is entirely responsible for good things happening or not. Consider the declining crime rates in many big cities. There’s lots of credit to go around to new policing techniques, including the use of data to help focus police departments’ resources on approaches that will do the most good. But even if those efforts hadn’t come to pass, it’s likely that crime rates would still be dropping – if less so. That’s because violent crime is disproportionately the work of young males. But birth rates have been lagging and median ages of cities have gone up and so there are simply fewer people inclined to commit violent crimes. We know we’re not the only ones out there who would like to have more information about the actual results of policies and programs. But even in good times, there’s a lack of dedicated budgets for the kinds of updates we think are important. What’s more, deducing causality is a complicated affair, and many state and local governments lack in-house staff who have been trained in the methodologies that should be used to come up with accurate conclusions. Even if an entity has data analysts on hand, they’ve got lots of other things to do than create outcome studies. Lest we seem to be going overboard here, it’s important to note that though there isn’t enough follow-up going on, there are certainly some places that have positions that do exactly that. Not long ago, for example, we wrote a kind of a valentine card to the performance auditors who do careful analyses about the issues that interfere with programs working. There are also full-time evaluators like those in New Mexico’s Legislative Finance Committee. We spend lots of time following the work of groups like these. But wouldn’t it be nice if more agencies took on these tasks, and shared the results, themselves. #StateandLocalManagement #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalPerformance #CityGovernmentManagement #CityPerformanceManagement #CityGovernmentPerformance #CountyGovernmentManagement #CountyPerformanceManagement #CountyGovernmentPerformance #StateandLocalInnovation #CityInnovation #CountyInnovation #StateandLocalPerformanceAudit #StateandLocalEvaluation #CityEvaluation #CountyEvaluation #NewMexicoLegislativeFinanceCommittee #StateandLocalProgramResults #ManagingForResults #StateandLocalOutcomes #StateandLocalTechInnovation #StateandLocalInnovationOutcomes #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • THE POWER OF SMALL COMMUNITIES

    For many years, our work about cities focused largely on those that had large populations. It always felt like we were doing our jobs well when we were able to interview a mayor, a city manager or administrator of cities like Los Angeles, Chicago, Dallas, Jacksonville, Seattle, Denver, and so on. But for a variety of reasons, over the last couple of years, we’ve been focusing more on smaller entities. In so doing, we’re writing about places that make up the bulk of the nation’s population. According to the most recent US Census data available, about 61% of Americans live in places with populations under 50,000. In recent years, we’ve interviewed busy city and town managers in entities that have under 10,000 in population, and many with under 100,000. We realize that what’s defined as “small” can vary wildly depending on region, attitude and context. Smart politicians realize the importance of smaller cities when it comes to election time. Although there’s emphasis in the press about the way residents of larger cities are thinking about candidates, it’s not uncommon for smaller places to provide just enough of a margin to sway a race one way or another. This can be true of national races, but when it comes to statewide posts, legislative districts often group multiple small towns together and as a result, rural and semi-suburban municipal leaders have substantial influence on the outcomes. As Chris Morrill, executive director of the Government Finance Officers Association, told us “Big cities get the headlines — but for millions of Americans, democracy lives on a quiet street where neighbors meet for a barbecue, in a town where you run into your government leaders at the grocery store, or the regional ball fields where parents cheer on their little league team. Many GFOA members serve these smaller cities, towns, and counties. The services they provide, the problems they solve, and futures they plan for, are as important as those faced by any large metro area”. As he points out, these communities have their own unique opportunities and challenges. In fact, it doesn’t matter whether a community is large or small. Both need roads, tax collection capacity, schools, parks, a way to run their finances and more. Since they tend to provide most of the services that larger ones do, smaller cities also need the same kinds of talent. But given their size, these positions often don’t exist at all, are part time, or are filled by individuals who carry the weight for a variety of jobs held by multiple individuals in larger places. In fact, towns and small cities often are required to operate with a town or city manager, combined department roles and a part-time finance director. As a result, just one vacancy can temporarily throw off the capacity of the community to provide essential services. Since they are often reliant on narrow streams of revenues, you might think that they’d be perennially on the hunt for grants from the federal government. But grant writing is a technical, complex process, and many lack the internal capacity to seek this potential source of money successfully. “Small communities need more dedicated staff to scan for grants constantly. Notices of funding opportunities (NOFOs) are lengthy, technical, and time-consuming to assess,” writes US Digital Response, a nonpartisan nonprofit that helps local state and tribal governments to obtain the kind of talent they need. “Free search tools like USDR’s Federal Grant Finder help, but small communities still need help to navigate the maze of federal grants.” On the positive side, the people who run small governments are often committed to them as a life goal, not as a route to something that seems bigger and better. Ron Holifield, a former city manager who authors “Ron on the Road,” a monthly column on this website, reflected to us that “the very best city council I ever worked for was in a city of 3,500 where every member ran for office because they cared about the community. Motivating them to run, and every decision they made, centered on giving back to the community they loved. Not one of them saw it as a steppingstone to higher office, or as a way of generating more business. They saw it as a way of giving back.” He went on to say that “Small towns I worked in epitomized the essence of servant leadership - it is not about me; it is not about now. They considered the implications of each decision on their friends and neighbors. They considered the implications of each decision on future generations. My experience has been that small towns ultimately make better decisions because, above all, they love their community and want to do what is right for it, not what benefits them the most personally.” Finally, though larger cities may consider their smaller neighbors as lacking high-class restaurants and major museums, they often rely on them for many of the services that they provide. For example, large cities that consume huge amounts of water rely on networks of reservoirs located elsewhere. Similarly, many of the clean energy resources like wind and solar emanate from facilities that are in rural counties, So, whether it’s big cities themselves, politicians, researchers or journalists, ignoring smaller places risks missing the real story. #CityGovernmentManagement #CityGovernmentPerformance #TownManagement #TownPerformance #SmallCityManagement #SmallCityPerformance #CityInnovation #SmallCityInnovation #SmallCityImpact #ServantLeadership #SmallCitiesAndServantLeadership #SmallCityStaffing #SmallCityResources #SmallCityChallenges #SmallCityStaffingChallenge #SmallCityRevenueChallenge #SmallCityGrantChallenge #SmallCityGrantAccess #SmallCityInfrastructureManagement #SmallCityHumanResourcesManagement #SmallCityTechnologyManagement #SmallCityProcurementManagement #SmallCitiesAndArtificialIntelligence #SmallCommunityWaterResources #SmallCommunityEnergyResources #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalPerformance #GovernmentFinanceOfficersAssociation #USDigitalResponse #ChrisMorrill #RonHolifield #RonOnTheRoad #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • SPECIAL FUND PROS AND CONS

    Special revenue funds are a well-established way for governments to earmark money for specific uses so that promised cash isn’t sometimes diverted due to temporary political preferences. As Investopedia explains, “special revenue funds are created by governments for specific projects to ensure financial accountability and transparency to taxpayers. These funds are distinct from general, capital, and rainy-day funds in government budgets.” Although special funds have many laudable uses, they can also be confusing, labor-intensive and overused. The cash that goes into special funds is used for a variety of needs and can come from multiple sources. The list begins with hotel and motel occupancy taxes which are supposed to be devoted to tourism promotion; 911 emergency surcharges, which are designed to be used exclusively for that service; voter-approved property tax levies or portions of the sales tax, which are maintained to help defray the costs of parks, libraries or emergency medical services. There are also instances in which individuals or organizations make a contribution specifying that it must be used for an initiative they want to nurture, like youth programs. For example, explains Investopedia, “A city might establish a special revenue fund to pay expenses associated with stormwater management. The money in this fund could only be used for stormwater management costs, such as street sweeping, drain and ditch cleaning, system maintenance, and a public awareness campaign. The city would be required to publicly report on where it collected the special revenue fund money from and how it spent the special revenue fund's budget.” There are hundreds of thousands of these funds in active use. Sometimes they are simply created by elected officials to demonstrate that they are prioritizing a particular service and want to guarantee to voters that they are committed to this funding regardless of prevailing economic conditions or other needs. Financial accounting and reporting standards established by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) provide caution about a proliferation of the number of funds that state and local governments introduce. “Only the minimum number of funds consistent with legal and operating requirements. should be established,” according to the June 2026 version of the summary statement of principles from the Governmental Accounting Research System (GARS). That’s because “unnecessary funds result in inflexibility, undue complexity, and inefficient financial administration." Over the course of years, we’ve sometimes been befuddled by the distinct differences between the numbers for all funds in an annual report and the accounting just for the general fund. One issue is that special funds that are loaded with cash can easily mislead people to think that an entity is in healthy economic shape, when in fact, the special revenue funds obscure shortages in the general fund. For example, a city might have $10 million dollars in these restricted funds, aimed at tree-planting or public awareness campaigns, when in fact the general fund, which is used to provide more essential services like road repair or emergency medical services, might be facing a shortfall. One issue, particularly in time of budget stress, is that money sitting in special funds can sometimes be transferred to core services. This happens with a certain amount of frequency, but the practice has been described as a “budget maneuver,” to be avoided according to the Volcker Alliance. Additionally, even though most cities and counties have financial staff that are overloaded with work maintaining and accounting for the entity’s major expenditures, every single additional restricted fund requires its own accounting and legal oversight. Though we don’t have a concrete example, we also fear that when there’s no powerful need for all the cash that comes into special revenue funds, there may be a tendency to retain large balances or absorb excess revenue on unnecessary equipment or contractors at the same time as basic municipal tasks are shortchanged. We’d like to suggest one way to help ensure that special revenue funds are used sensibly and skillfully. It makes sense to have a policy that mandates that these funds are reviewed on a regular basis to make certain that they are being used as designed, to uncover inactive accounts and to consider sunsetting them, if necessary. As things stand, it can easily be the case that special revenue funds can continue in the same way as they were created without the same kind of budgetary analysis that occurs with the general fund. #SpecialfundProsAndCons #StateandLocalGovernmentBudgeting #CityBudgeting #StateBudgeting #Countybudgeting #StateandLocalGovernmentFinance #StateandLocalSpecialFund Management #StateandLocalSpecialFundAccounting #StateandLocalManagement #StateandLocalFinancialPerformance #CityManagement #CityPerformance #CountyManagement #CountyPerformance #StateandLocalBudgetTransparency #StateandLocalSpecialRevenueFunds #SusettingStateandLocalSpecialFunds #CityBudgetTransparency #CountyBudgetTransparency #CitySpecialRevenueFunds #CountySpecialRevenueFunds #StateandLocalSpecialFundInflexibility #StateandLocalSpecialFundComplexity #StateandLocalSpecialFundReview #StateandLocalBudgetaryManeuvers #StateandLocalFinancialReporting #CityFinancialReporting #CountyFinancialReporting #VolckerAlliance #Investopedia #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeneInc

  • 3 CHEERS FOR PERFORMANCE AUDITS

    Two weeks ago, we were in a conversation with a couple of smart local government observers, and we mentioned that our work relied regularly on performance audits. The conversation took place on Zoom and so we were able to tell that our words seemed to be a bit mystifying to them. That led us to a few polite queries, which uncovered the sad truth – they were pretty much unaware of the existence of performance audits altogether. We believe, modestly, that we may make as good or better use of performance audits in our writing as anyone else out there. Not only do they help us uncover stories about individual entities, they also have aided us in identifying trends across a wide swath of cities, counties and states. For example, in April, we wrote a management news item about places with an inconsistent record of required safety inspections. We picked up on this by tracking audits from Oregon, Massachusetts, Dallas, Salt Lake City and elsewhere. First, let’s describe, specifically what we mean by performance audits: We’re thinking of reports and studies that are usually generated by elected and appointed state and local auditors. But other branches of government do performance audits as well, including comptrollers. New York state’s comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, for example, churns out dozens of them – and not just for the state but for municipalities. Explains the Ohio Auditor’s Office, “Performance audits, like financial audits, are conducted in three phases: planning, fieldwork, and reporting. Reports are written to be accessible to both government officials and taxpayers; the data are often presented visually to make the information more meaningful to all readers. . . “Staffing and employee compensation, program results, contract management, transportation systems, and facility and asset use are all areas commonly included in a performance audit. Results might identify cost savings, duplicative or underused services that could be reduced or eliminated, and gaps and overlaps in services.” In many places performance audits have a very good batting average. For example, a spring 2026 Louisiana Legislative Audit review considered 83 recommendations from previous years (mostly from 2023), with 77 (92.8%) either implemented or in the process of being implemented and six (7.2%) not implemented. Even better was Colorado, where a report issued last November found that ‘During a 5-year period, July 2019 through June 2024, auditees agreed or partially agreed to implement 1,179 of the (Office of State Auditor’s) recommendations (98%).” San Jose’s auditor’s office is particularly transparent about the success of its recommendations. In fact, according to the city auditor, “Our office provides a written report on the status of open audit recommendations to the City Council every six months . . . interactive dashboards allow users to view and sort open audit recommendations by department, type, date, potential budget savings, and target year.” While the work from many performance shops is put to good use, it’s clear to us that performance audits don’t always have the impact that the performance auditors might like. In fact, it’s not uncommon for us to come across an audit that notes that only a handful of the recommendations of a prior audit about the same topic have been followed. Notwithstanding the rate at which the recommendations are adapted, auditors can point to problems that require attention from elected leaders and program managers. For example, in March, 2026, Oakland’s Office of the City Auditor took a close look at the city’s agencies that have the responsibility of providing oversight to the Oakland Police Department. Even though the numbers are improving, Oakland is still clearly a high crime city and sufficient oversight is critical. Among the auditor’s findings were that “Vacancies, frozen positions, low minimum staffing requirements, and leadership turnover have hindered the police oversight agencies’ ability to fulfill their legally mandated duties.” What’s more, “functional separation from the City Administration in matters of budget and hiring, for example – would help to ensure the police oversight agencies have sufficient resources and administrative authority to meet their legal mandates.” As the City Auditor Michael C. Houston, wrote, “In recent years the City has not provided enough resources to deliver on its stated values and principles. Our audit confirms that police oversight is an example of this. The city and the community have vocalized a commitment to rigorous police oversight, but the city has not given enough resources . . . to deliver rigorous police oversight.” It’s important to note that performance audits aren’t always the bearers of bad news. Sometimes after careful examination, they find that agencies and programs have been improving in their work. Consider for example, the Atlanta City Auditor’s office June 2026 follow-up to a 2012 audit of its tax allocation district program, a designated area where future increases in local property tax revenues generated by new development are used to pay for public improvements in the district. According to the auditor, it made six recommendations back then and the city and its official economic development authority (Invest Atlanta) made all of them. As Invest Atlanta reported, the audit found that the agency and the city have strengthened tracking, reporting and oversight of the Tax Allocation District (TAD) program. According to the new audit, “The city has required Invest Atlanta to undertake third-party assessments every three years to determine the status of each tax allocation districts redevelopment goals.” Further, with the exception of one district, the remainder “have enough funds to pay off existing debt. . . “ #StateandLocalPerformanceAudit #StateandLocalGovernmentManagement #CityGovernmentManagement #CountyGovernmentManagement #CityPerformanceAudit #CountyPerformanceAudit #StatePerformanceAudit #StateandLocalPerformanceManagement #CityPerformanceManagement #CountyPerformanceManagement #StateandLocalGovernmentPerformance #StateandLocalGovernmentData #StateandLocalAuditRecommendations #CityAuditRecommendations #CountyAuditRecommendations #StateAuditRecommendations #AtlantCityAuditor #OaklandOfficeCityAuditor #LouisianaLegislativeAuditor #OhioStateAuditor #ColoradoStateAuditor #SanJoseCityAuditor #PerformanceAuditDashboard #StateandLocalPoliceOversight #StateandLocalInspection #PerformanceAuditInspectionFinding #StateandLocalAuditNews #BandGReport #BarrettandGreeenInc

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Management, State and Local Performance Audit, State and Local Government Human Resources, State and Local Government Performance Measurement, State and Local Performance Management, State and Local Government Performance, State and Local Government Budgeting, State and Local Government Data, Governor Executive Orders, State Medicaid Management, State Local Policy Implementation, City Government Management, County Government Management, State Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Equity and DEI Policy and Management, City Government Performance, State and Local Data Governance, and State Local Government Generative AI Policy and Management, inspirational women, sponsors, Privacy, 

 

Barrett and Greene, Dedicated to State and Local Government, State and Local Government Management, State and Local Managemen

SIGN UP FOR SPECIAL NEWS JUST FOR YOU.

Get exclusive subscriber-only links to news and articles and the latest information on this website sent directly in your inbox.

Thanks for Subscribing. You'll now recieve updates directly to your inbox.

Copyright @ Barrett and Greene, Inc.  |  All rights Reserved  |  Built By Boost  |  Privacy  |  212-684-5687  |  greenebarrett@gmail.com

bottom of page